• Categories

  • Archives

    « Home

    New York Times: Prop 8 Donor Web Site Shows Disclosure Law Is 2-Edged Sword

    The New York Times has an interesting story on a Web site that uses Google Maps and data on people donating money to support anti-gay marriage Proposition 8 to create a map of the donors’ locations. Some donors have reported harassment and threats. The donor data is made publicly available under California’s campaign finance disclosure laws.

    Visitors [to the Web site] can see markers indicating a contributor’s name, approximate location, amount donated and, if the donor listed it, employer. That is often enough information for interested parties to find the rest — like an e-mail or home address. The identity of the site’s creators, meanwhile, is unknown; they have maintained their anonymity. is the latest, most striking example of how information collected through disclosure laws intended to increase the transparency of the political process, magnified by the powerful lens of the Web, may be undermining the same democratic values that the regulations were to promote.

    With tools like eightmaps — and there are bound to be more of them — strident political partisans can challenge their opponents directly, one voter at a time. The results, some activists fear, could discourage people from participating in the political process altogether.

    That is why the soundtrack to is a loud gnashing of teeth among civil libertarians, privacy advocates and people supporting open government. The site pits their cherished values against each other: political transparency and untarnished democracy versus privacy and freedom of speech.

    “When I see those maps, it does leave me with a bit of a sick feeling in my stomach,” said Kim Alexander, president of the California Voter Foundation, which has advocated for open democracy. “This is not really the intention of voter disclosure laws. But that’s the thing about technology. You don’t really know where it is going to take you.”

    Leave a Reply